Guilbeault Will Not Promise No Increase In Canada’s Oil And Gas Exports

On June 9, 2023 Guilbeault indicated that he will not promise to “limit Canada’s oil exports by requiring that they not exceed Canada's current percentage of total world exports.” This came in the form of his response to a petition presented to the House of Commons by Robert Oliphant (who is also a Liberal). See link.
 
Part of the petition states, “Increasing Canadian oil export would negate some or all the gains made from domestic reductions and contribute to an increase in climate change damage to many parts of the country.” This part of the petition implies and recognizes that further "downstream emissions" are created when the exported/sold product, oil, is used/burned.

Yet, in response to that petition, Guilbeault appears to be ignoring the subject of downstream emissions when he states,
Quote:
“[Our] objective is to limit the emissions from the production of oil and natural gas as the cap becomes more stringent over time, irrespective of whether the production is for domestic consumption or for export. Accordingly, the purpose of the emissions cap is to encourage private sector investment in decarbonizing the oil and gas sector; it is not a cap on oil and gas production.

The International Energy Agency (IEA) expects there to be demand for oil and natural gas by 2050. As the Canadian oil and gas sector decarbonizes to meet our climate targets, it can position itself to be the lowest emission intensity supplier of oil to meet this demand.”

End Quote

Guilbeault appears to be ignoring the part of the petition which states, “Increasing Canadian oil export would negate some or all the gains made from domestic reductions.”

 
In other words, he appears to be ignoring the part of the petition that points to the fact that, globally speaking, the burning of the exported fuel itself will increase global emissions far more than any domestic reduction in emissions from the process of producing that fuel.

 
That fact is true regardless of whether or not Canada can “position itself to be the lowest emission intensity supplier of oil”in a global market.

Just because the “International Energy Agency (IEA) expects there to be demand for oil and natural gas by 2050” doesn’t mean that those expectations align with a livable planet: The IPCC has said in its Special Report on Global Warming of 1.5 °C  that, for global warming to be limited to 1.5 °C, "Global net human-caused emissions of carbon dioxide (CO2) would need to fall by about 45 percent from 2010 levels by 2030, reaching 'net zero' around 2050.” See link.  

What equation is Guilbeault using to arrive at that net zero by 2050 or is he using any equation at all?

Also, is Guilbeault operating on the assumption that  importers of oil will choose Canada's oil over others simply because it may, in the future (if all goes according to his market incentive plans) be produced with lower emissions than the alternatives? That multi-faceted assumption exposes our planet to the risk of exceeding the temperatures that are compatible with a livable planet.

Also, on June 26, 2023, the International Institute for Sustainable Development released an extensive report which concludes that…“[Global] buyers of Canadian oil are focused on price, reliability, and quality—not on environmental, social, and governance (ESG) credentials.” See link. This is an urgent "writing on the wall" message about financially protecting Canadians from a global downturn in demand for our oil and gas exports.

But the most disturbing part of his response is the fact that Guilbeault appears to be ignoring any discussion of downstream emissions even after the petition explicitly flagged those emissions. 

Footnote: Also interesting are these facts:

His response to the petition was tabled on June 9, 2023 when Ottawa was in a blanket of smoke from wildfires. 

On June 17, 2019 the Liberal government declared a climate emergency. A day later June 18, 2019, they approved the TMX pipeline which sends oil to a coastal port for export. 

On June 19, 2019, Guilbeault announced that he was seeking the Liberal Party of Canada nomination for the riding of Laurier—Sainte-Marie in the 2019 Canadian federal election.